Which Sweetener For…
Pick the things that matter for what you are making, and this page shows what our sourced records say about each sweetener, need by need. It is a filter, not a recommendation: it does not rank anything, it does not know your situation, and where a record holds no sourced value it says so instead of guessing.
Disclosure: the operator of this site sells erythritol-based products, so we have a commercial interest in some of the sweeteners this tool covers. Every figure links to its source so you can check it. See our terms for how we handle this.
What our records say
Xylitol: Life-threatening to dogs
MECHANISM: in humans xylitol does not stimulate insulin release; in dogs it is absorbed rapidly and triggers a potent insulin release, causing profound hypoglycaemia within 10 to 60 MINUTES. Signs: vomiting, then decreased activity, weakness, staggering, incoordination, collapse, seizures. Serious effects can be delayed 12 to 24 hours, so a well-looking dog still needs a vet. Also called BIRCH SUGAR or WOOD SUGAR on labels. Present in gum, mints, sugar-free candy, baked goods, cough syrup, chewable vitamins, mouthwash, toothpaste, some peanut and nut butters, and "skinny" ice cream. Ferrets are also affected; cats appear largely spared. Never use human toothpaste on a pet.
US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026Aspartame: Mandatory label warning for people with phenylketonuria (PKU)
Aspartame is hydrolysed on digestion into phenylalanine, aspartic acid and methanol. People with phenylketonuria (PKU) — a rare inherited disorder, screened for in newborns via a routine heel-prick test — cannot metabolise phenylalanine normally, and it accumulates to harmful levels. 21 CFR 172.804(d)(2) makes the warning mandatory: every aspartame-containing product must state "PHENYLKETONURICS: CONTAINS PHENYLALANINE", required to appear "prominently and conspicuously" in bold type on a clear contrasting background. EFSA's 2013 re-evaluation is explicit that the ADI itself does not apply to this population: PKU patients "require strict adherence to a diet low in phenylalanine" regardless of the ADI figure. Separately, EFSA modelled even PKU HETEROZYGOTES (genetic carriers, not affected) at intakes up to the ADI and found no risk to a developing fetus from phenylalanine exposure via aspartame — a safety margin that does not extend to someone who actually has PKU.
Cornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026A sugar substitute cannot treat a low blood glucose
Low blood glucose is below 70 mg/dL. The ADA's stated rule is 15 grams of FAST-ACTING carbohydrate, then recheck after 15 minutes — none of the substitutes on this site qualify, because not raising blood glucose is the entire point of them. Severe hypoglycaemia is an emergency needing help from others; if someone is unconscious and glucagon is unavailable or nobody knows how to use it, call 911. Your own care plan takes priority over anything written here.
American Diabetes Association clinical guidance checked 31 Aug 2026Each need below reads one named fact in each of our sweetener records. A record can answer Yes, No, or with something that is not a plain yes or no. Where a record holds no sourced fact, the page says "No sourced figure" and does not count it either way.
Rows are in the order of our record file. Nothing here is ranked or scored, and no sweetener is suggested over another.
- Yes
- The sourced fact says the record meets the need.
- No
- The sourced fact says it does not.
- Not a plain yes or no
- There is a sourced fact, but it is conditional, disputed, or in words where the need asks for a figure. Read the cell.
- No sourced figure
- Our record holds nothing sourced for this need. That is not a yes and not a no.
Start from a situation
- Baking, where bulk and browning matter
- Something that will be heated
- A dog lives in the household
- Someone in the household has PKU
- If you are managing diabetes
Every sweetener against every need
Each cell links to the fact it rests on, with its source and the date we last opened it.
Baking, where bulk and browning matter
Two needs read together: whether the record says the sweetener adds bulk, and whether it says it browns. The last column says whether a record is Yes on both.
A row can read "No sourced figure" for an ordinary ingredient, sugar included, when our record for it does not hold that fact. That is a gap in our records, not a finding about the ingredient.
| Sweetener | Adds bulk | Browns | Read together |
|---|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Yes | No | No on: Browns |
| Allulose | Yes | Yes | Yes on both |
| Monk Fruit | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Stevia | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure | No plain yes or no on: Adds bulk, Browns |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure | No plain yes or no on: Adds bulk, Browns |
| Sucralose | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Aspartame | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Saccharin | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Neotame | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Advantame | No | No sourced figure | No on: Adds bulk. No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Tagatose | Yes | Yes | Yes on both |
| Maltitol | Yes | Not a plain yes or no | No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Sorbitol | Yes | Not a plain yes or no | No plain yes or no on: Browns |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Yes | Yes | Yes on both |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure | No plain yes or no on: Adds bulk, Browns |
A dog lives in the household
How this need is read. This need reads one fact in each record: its dog-toxicity warning. A record that carries the warning does not meet the need, and the warning is printed in full above the table. No record holds a sourced statement that a sweetener is safe for dogs, so no row here can say Yes. A row without a warning means our record holds nothing about dogs. It does not mean we checked and found it harmless.
Xylitol: Life-threatening to dogs
MECHANISM: in humans xylitol does not stimulate insulin release; in dogs it is absorbed rapidly and triggers a potent insulin release, causing profound hypoglycaemia within 10 to 60 MINUTES. Signs: vomiting, then decreased activity, weakness, staggering, incoordination, collapse, seizures. Serious effects can be delayed 12 to 24 hours, so a well-looking dog still needs a vet. Also called BIRCH SUGAR or WOOD SUGAR on labels. Present in gum, mints, sugar-free candy, baked goods, cough syrup, chewable vitamins, mouthwash, toothpaste, some peanut and nut butters, and "skinny" ice cream. Ferrets are also affected; cats appear largely spared. Never use human toothpaste on a pet.
US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026- Dog warning: Xylitol.
- No sourced figure: Erythritol, Allulose, Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sugar (sucrose), Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre), Yacon syrup.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Allulose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | Life-threatening to dogsUS Food and Drug Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026The full warning is printed directly above this table. | Dog warning |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Neotame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Advantame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Tagatose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Maltitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sorbitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
PKU: what the label rules say
How this need is read. This need reads two labelling facts: the PKU label warning, where a record carries one, and the PKU status row, which records a sourced statement that no label warning is required. "No warning required" is a fact about the label rule. It does not say the sweetener contains no phenylalanine, and it is not dietary guidance for PKU; the note beside it, shown open, says what the rule rests on. A record with neither fact is shown as "No sourced figure". That is an absence in our records, not a statement about what the sweetener contains.
Aspartame: Mandatory label warning for people with phenylketonuria (PKU)
Aspartame is hydrolysed on digestion into phenylalanine, aspartic acid and methanol. People with phenylketonuria (PKU) — a rare inherited disorder, screened for in newborns via a routine heel-prick test — cannot metabolise phenylalanine normally, and it accumulates to harmful levels. 21 CFR 172.804(d)(2) makes the warning mandatory: every aspartame-containing product must state "PHENYLKETONURICS: CONTAINS PHENYLALANINE", required to appear "prominently and conspicuously" in bold type on a clear contrasting background. EFSA's 2013 re-evaluation is explicit that the ADI itself does not apply to this population: PKU patients "require strict adherence to a diet low in phenylalanine" regardless of the ADI figure. Separately, EFSA modelled even PKU HETEROZYGOTES (genetic carriers, not affected) at intakes up to the ADI and found no risk to a developing fetus from phenylalanine exposure via aspartame — a safety margin that does not extend to someone who actually has PKU.
Cornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026- No warning required: Neotame, Advantame.
- PKU warning: Aspartame.
- No sourced figure: Erythritol, Allulose, Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Sucralose, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre), Yacon syrup.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Allulose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | Mandatory label warning for people with phenylketonuria (PKU)Cornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026The full warning is printed directly above this table. | PKU warning |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Neotame | PKU warning label: No PKU warning required — unlike aspartame, despite being an aspartame derivativeUS Food and Drug Administration, Federal Register 67(131):45300, 9… regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteTHE COUNTERINTUITIVE FACT ABOUT THIS SWEETENER. Neotame is structurally aspartame with a 3,3-dimethylbutyl group added to the amino nitrogen, and it still contains a phenylalanine methyl ester moiety — yet 21 CFR 172.829 contains NO phenylketonuria warning requirement, where 21 CFR 172.804 makes one mandatory for aspartame. FDA's own arithmetic in the 2002 approval, which is unusually clean: the added group blocks peptidase cleavage, so only "approximately 13 to 17 percent of the total available phenylalanine in the ingested neotame is released into the plasma after absorption; the remainder is eliminated in feces and urine as DMB-Asp-Phe." Neotame is 44% phenylalanine by weight, but at 7,000-13,000x sweetness the mass consumed is minuscule: FDA's 90th-percentile estimated daily intake is 0.10 mg/kg bw/d (6 mg/day) for a 60 kg adult and 0.17 mg/kg bw/d (3.4 mg/day) for a 20 kg child aged 2-5, giving estimated 90th-percentile phenylalanine intakes of 2.6 mg and 1.5 mg respectively. Against that, ordinary dietary phenylalanine for a healthy adult is 2.5 to 10 GRAMS per day — three to four orders of magnitude more. FDA's conclusion for the population that actually matters, quoted directly: "Even for the PKU homozygous child, the incremental amount of phenylalanine intake that can be expected from neotame is insignificant, i.e., equivalent to no more than 0.3 to 0.4 percent of the daily phenylalanine intake of the PKU homozygous child." EFSA reached the same place independently in 2025: phenylalanine formed from neotame at the ADI would raise physiological phenylalanine concentration by less than 1%, safe including for people heterozygous for phenylalanine hydroxylase deficiency. NOTE THE LIMIT OF THIS: it says the exposure is negligible, NOT that neotame is phenylalanine-free. Anyone managing PKU should still be reading ingredient lists against their own clinical plan, not this record. | No warning required |
| Advantame | PKU warning label: No PKU warning required — and JECFA stated explicitly that its ADI applies to people with phenylketonuriaJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteSame counterintuitive position as neotame, but better documented. Advantame is an aspartame derivative and retains a phenylalanine methyl ester moiety, yet 21 CFR 172.803 contains NO phenylketonuria warning requirement — the only labelling provision is the special-dietary-use cross-reference to part 105 — where 21 CFR 172.804(d)(2) makes the warning mandatory for aspartame. JECFA went further than the CFR's silence and addressed the question head-on: "The Committee agreed that the ADI also applies to those individuals with phenylketonuria, as the formation of phenylalanine from the normal use of advantame would not be significant in relation to this condition." The mechanism is the same as neotame's and more extreme: at ~20,000x sucrose the mass consumed is so small that the phenylalanine liberated is negligible against ordinary dietary intake of 2.5-10 g/day. AS WITH NEOTAME, note the limit: this says exposure is negligible, NOT that advantame is phenylalanine-free. Anyone managing PKU should work from their clinical plan and the ingredient list, not from this record. | No warning required |
| Tagatose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Maltitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sorbitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
Adds bulk to a recipe
How this need is read. This need reads the bulk contribution fact. Our records use two words there: "bulking", read as Yes, and "none", read as No.
- Yes: Erythritol, Allulose, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre).
- No: Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
- No sourced figure: Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Yacon syrup.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Bulk contribution: BulkingEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteUsed as a bulk sweetener, but a 1:1 weight swap under-sweetens because it delivers only 60-80% of sucrose sweetness. | Yes |
| Allulose | Bulk contribution: BulkingXie X, Yu L, Lin Q, Huang D; Journal… peer reviewed checked 30 Aug 2026NoteUsed at sugar-like weights, but above 20% sucrose replacement in sponge cake hardness and chewiness rose significantly, and specific volume fell from 3.36 to 2.96 cm3/g at 50% replacement. A 1:1 swap also under-sweetens at ~70% relative sweetness. | Yes |
| Monk Fruit | Bulk contribution: NoneUS FDA, Office of Food Additive Safety regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteHigh-intensity sweetener used at milligram levels; contributes no volume, structure, browning or mouthfeel. Any product that fills a measuring cup is doing so with something else. This is why tabletop "monk fruit" is usually a blend. | No |
| Stevia | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteHigh-intensity; contributes no volume, structure, browning or mouthfeel. Anything cup-for-cup is mostly carrier. | No |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteHigh-intensity; used in milligrams. Anything cup-for-cup is mostly carrier. | No |
| Aspartame | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 31 Aug 2026NoteHigh-intensity; used in milligrams. Anything cup-for-cup is mostly carrier. | No |
| Saccharin | Bulk contribution: NoneCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteHigh-intensity; used in milligrams. Anything cup-for-cup is mostly carrier. Saccharin is also known for a bitter/metallic aftertaste at higher concentrations, which is why it is very often blended with another sweetener (historically cyclamate outside the US, now more often sucralose or aspartame) rather than used alone — not independently sourced to a primary document this pass, recorded as common-knowledge context only. | No |
| Acesulfame Potassium | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteHigh-intensity; used in milligrams. Anything cup-for-cup is mostly carrier. | No |
| Neotame | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteHigh-intensity, used in milligrams. Contributes no volume, structure, browning or mouthfeel. | No |
| Advantame | Bulk contribution: NoneUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteHigh-intensity; contributes no volume, structure, browning or mouthfeel. At 20,000x, the amount in a finished product is often measured in micrograms per serving. | No |
| Tagatose | Bulk contribution: BulkingJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (INCHEM mirror… regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteUsed at sugar-like weights; at about 0.9 sucrose sweetness, close to a 1:1 swap. JECFA lists its functions as sweetener, texturizer, stabilizer, humectant and formulation aid. | Yes |
| Maltitol | Bulk contribution: BulkingRoze M, Crucean D, Diler G, et al.; Foods… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Funded by the Pays de la Loire region and the EU Horizon 2020 SWEET project; "The authors declare no conflict of interest."Note"Maltitol presents characteristics close to sucrose, with similar molecular weight (disaccharide), melting point and hygroscopicity" — with near-sugar sweetness, the reason it is the default polyol in sugar-free chocolate. | Yes |
| Sorbitol | Bulk contribution: BulkingFood and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteJECFA's functional uses: "Sweetener, humectant, sequestrant, texturizer, stabilizer, bulking agent". FDA's good-manufacturing maximums run from 12% of most foods to 99% of hard candy and cough drops (21 CFR 184.1835(d)). | Yes |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Bulk contribution: BulkingJackson PPJ, Wijeyesekera A, Rastall RA; Food Science &… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "CONFLICT OF INTEREST None to declare."NoteShort chains give bulk and mild sweetness; long-chain inulin "can form fat‐mimicking gels" at concentrations above 10-20%, which is why it also appears as a fat replacer. FDA's first GRAS notice for chicory inulin (GRN 118) was for use "as a bulking agent". | Yes |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
Browns
How this need is read. This need reads the browning fact. Yes means the record says the sweetener browns, or takes part in Maillard browning. No means the record's value is "none". Two records say there is no Maillard browning but the bake is not colourless; that is shown as not a plain yes or no, and the cell gives the sentence. Our records hold no separate fact on caramelisation.
- Yes: Allulose, Tagatose, Inulin (chicory root fibre).
- No: Erythritol.
- Not a plain yes or no: Maltitol, Sorbitol.
- No sourced figure: Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame, Yacon syrup.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Browning: NoneEuropean Commission regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NotePolyols do not participate in Maillard browning; the additive specification caps reducing substances at 0.3% as D-glucose. | No |
| Allulose | Browning: HighXie X, Yu L, Lin Q, Huang D; Journal… peer reviewed checked 30 Aug 2026NoteBrowns MORE than sucrose, not less. In sponge cake, lightness fell and redness/yellowness rose with allulose level, with the browning index rising sharply above 20% sucrose replacement and antioxidant activity nearly tripling at the highest level. Practical consequence: the window between caramelised and burnt is narrower than with sugar. | Yes |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Neotame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Advantame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Tagatose | Browning: HighTaylor TP, Fasina O, Bell LN; Journal of Food… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026NoteA reducing ketohexose, so Maillard-active like allulose and unlike every polyol here. Cookies made with tagatose instead of sucrose were "harder and darker with a lower spread" (Taylor 2008, abstract); panellists liked the 100%-tagatose colour but not its sweetness, and a 50% swap matched the control on liking. The GRN 977 notifier calls it "a very effective browning agent" — a manufacturer's words, consistent with the bake data. | Yes |
| Maltitol | Browning: No Maillard browning, but not colourlessRoze M, Crucean D, Diler G, et al.; Foods… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Funded by the Pays de la Loire region and the EU Horizon 2020 SWEET project; "The authors declare no conflict of interest."NoteNot a reducing sugar, so it cannot brown by the Maillard route — yet in a controlled biscuit study the authors found it "unexpected that sorbitol and maltitol biscuits are, after all, exceptionally colourful". Maltitol biscuits came out lighter than sugar ones, especially at the edges. Write "browns less", not "does not brown". Independent study (EU Horizon 2020 SWEET project; no conflicts declared). | Not a plain yes or no |
| Sorbitol | Browning: No Maillard browning, but not colourlessRoze M, Crucean D, Diler G, et al.; Foods… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Funded by the Pays de la Loire region and the EU Horizon 2020 SWEET project; "The authors declare no conflict of interest."NoteNot a reducing sugar, so no Maillard route — yet the controlled biscuit study found it "unexpected that sorbitol and maltitol biscuits are, after all, exceptionally colourful". Write "browns less", not "does not brown". Independent study (EU Horizon 2020 SWEET project; no conflicts declared). | Not a plain yes or no |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Browning: Takes part in Maillard browningJackson PPJ, Wijeyesekera A, Rastall RA; Food Science &… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "CONFLICT OF INTEREST None to declare."Note"ITF is a mixture of reducing and nonreducing oligosaccharides, therefore is susceptible to participation in the Maillard reaction"; bread with 5% inulin-type fructans "darkened 3 min quicker" than bread with 0 or 3%. | Yes |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
Heat stable
How this need is read. This need reads the heat stability fact, which is a short sentence, not a figure. It is read as Yes only where the record says "Heat stable" outright and as No only where it says "Not heat stable". A sentence that is conditional, or that records a disagreement between regulators, is shown as not a plain yes or no. Many records have no heat stability fact at all, and this page does not assume one.
- Yes: Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
- No: Aspartame.
- Not a plain yes or no: Sucralose, Inulin (chicory root fibre), Yacon syrup.
- No sourced figure: Erythritol, Allulose, Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Saccharin, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Allulose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | Heat stability: Disputed between regulatorsEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteFDA: sucralose "is heat stable, meaning it stays sweet even when used at high temperatures during baking, making it suitable as a sugar substitute in baked goods." EFSA, December 2025, on a proposed extension into fine bakery wares: "the Panel could not conclude on the safety of the proposed extension of use of E 955 in this FC", citing uncertainty about chlorinated compound formation across diverse baking processes — while noting that controlled studies showed no significant increases in 3-MCPD or PCDD/PCDF. Note the two are answering different questions: FDA is describing sweetness retention, EFSA is assessing what forms during baking. A formulator needs both. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Aspartame | Heat stability: Not heat stableCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026NoteFDA states this plainly, unlike sucralose's regulator-vs-regulator dispute: aspartame "is not heat stable and loses its sweetness when heated, so it typically isn't used in baked goods." Note the gap between LAW and PRACTICE: 21 CFR 172.804 does list baked goods and baking mixes as a permitted category (aspartame capped at 0.5% by weight of the ready-to-bake product) — legally permitted, functionally impractical, which is exactly why it is rarely seen there. This is the opposite functional profile from allulose, which browns and caramelises like sugar. | No |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | Heat stability: Heat stableUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026NoteFDA states this plainly, no regulator dispute (contrast sucralose's FDA-vs-EFSA disagreement and aspartame's outright instability): Ace-K "is heat stable, meaning it stays sweet even when used at hot temperatures during baking, making it suitable as a sugar substitute in baked goods." This stability is the practical reason Ace-K is so often blended with aspartame in beverages: aspartame supplies a cleaner taste profile, Ace-K supplies shelf-life and heat tolerance the blend would otherwise lack. | Yes |
| Neotame | Heat stability: Heat stableUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteFDA: "It is heat stable, meaning it stays sweet even when used at high temperatures during baking, making it suitable as a sugar substitute in baked goods." This is the OPPOSITE of aspartame, which FDA states plainly is not heat stable — the practical functional difference between the two, and a large part of why neotame exists. | Yes |
| Advantame | Heat stability: Heat stableUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteFDA: "It is heat stable, meaning it stays sweet even when used at high temperatures during baking, making it suitable as a sugar substitute in baked goods." Same functional advantage over aspartame as neotame has. | Yes |
| Tagatose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Maltitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sorbitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Heat stability: Stable at neutral pH; breaks down below pH 4Jackson PPJ, Wijeyesekera A, Rastall RA; Food Science &… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "CONFLICT OF INTEREST None to declare."Note"The hydrolysis of ITF and scFOS is pH dependent with a little‐to‐no breakdown of ITF at pH >4, while at pH <4, ITF are hydrolyzed", yielding shorter chains and fructose. In acidic drinks and yogurts the fibre on the label can overstate what is left by the end of shelf life, and the fructose released is a sugar. Toasting bread lost little fructan in the study the review cites. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Yacon syrup | Heat stability: FOS turn into free sugars with storage, acid and heatManrique I, Párraga A, Hermann M; Centro Internacional de… reference checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: CIP develops and promotes yacon syrup processing; the manual also makes untested benefit claims (weight, caries), which this record does not use.NoteCIP: in the harvested root, "alrededor del 30 a 40% de los FOS se habrán transformado en azúcares simples" after a week at room temperature; in syrup, about 25% of FOS convert at pH 4 and 45% at pH 3 over six months, so CIP keeps syrup at pH 4 or above. The syrup in the Brazilian trials was made at pH 3.7. CIP also reports that syrup bottled at pH 5 changed very little over twelve months. No data on FOS survival in home baking were found. | Not a plain yes or no |
0 kcal per gram in our record
How this need is read. This need reads the per-gram calorie figure in each record, in kcal per gram of the sweetener itself. Yes means the figure is 0 and No means it is above 0. Not every figure is an FDA per-gram factor, and some rest on FDA enforcement discretion; the notes, shown open, say what each one rests on. A record that describes calories in words instead of a per-gram figure is shown as not a plain yes or no. This is not a statement about a finished product or a serving.
- Yes: Erythritol, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
- No: Allulose, Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre).
- Not a plain yes or no: Monk Fruit, Aspartame, Yacon syrup.
- No sourced figure: Stevia, Sucralose.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Calories: 0 kcal per gramElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026 | Yes |
| Allulose | Calories: 0.4 kcal per gramUS FDA, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteENFORCEMENT DISCRETION, not a rule. FDA states that under 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(B) "a caloric value of 4 kcal/g must currently be used for allulose because it is a carbohydrate", and that it merely intends not to enforce that pending rulemaking. Two citizen petitions asked for 0.4 and 0.2; FDA chose the higher figure because it "would not underestimate the caloric contribution". | No |
| Monk Fruit | Calories: Negligible at use levelsUS FDA, Office of Food Additive Safety regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteDeliberately not stated as "0 kcal/g". No authority has assigned monk fruit extract a caloric factor the way FDA assigned erythritol 0 and allulose 0.4. What is documented is the exposure: mean SGFE intake up to 1.6 mg/kg bw/day, 90th percentile 4.2 mg/kg bw/day in healthy adults. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | Calories: 4 kcal per gramCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteThe general factor for total carbohydrate under 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(B). This is the number every "reduced calorie" claim on this site is implicitly measured against. | No |
| Xylitol | Calories: 2.4 kcal per gramCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteThe HIGHEST of any polyol FDA assigns a factor to, and 60% of sugar's 4 kcal/g — nowhere near erythritol's 0. The full FDA table: erythritol 0, mannitol 1.6, isomalt 2.0, lactitol 2.0, maltitol 2.1, xylitol 2.4, sorbitol 2.6, hydrogenated starch hydrolysates 3.0. Anyone treating "sugar alcohol" as a single low-calorie category is wrong by a factor of infinity at one end of that list. | No |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | Calories: Contains calories; negligible at use levelsUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteFDA: aspartame "contains calories, but consumers will likely use less than they would of table sugar." It is metabolised as two ordinary amino acids (phenylalanine, aspartic acid) plus methanol, so unlike saccharin or Ace-K it does yield energy; it is negligible in practice only because of the tiny mass used per serving at about 200x sweetness. CHANGED 2026-10-27 from calories_per_g_us = 4.0: that field is for a per-gram factor an authority assigned, and the cited FDA page gives no per-gram figure. The commonly quoted 4 kcal/g (e.g. EUFIC) was not found in an FDA, EFSA or JECFA document this pass. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Saccharin | Calories: 0 kcal per gramCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteCONFIRMED 2026-09-01 against FDA's own page, which states it flatly: saccharin "contains no calories." CFR 180.37 independently frames saccharin as a "non-nutritive sweetening agent," not merely low-calorie — unlike aspartame (metabolised as amino acids, so it does yield energy, negligible at use levels) or allulose (metabolised only partially, FDA-assigned 0.4 kcal/g by enforcement discretion), saccharin passes through without being metabolised as an energy source at all. No FDA nutrition-labelling regulation assigning it a specific non-zero per-gram factor was found this pass (it does not appear in 21 CFR 101.9's polyol caloric-factor table, which does not cover high-intensity sweeteners in any case). | Yes |
| Acesulfame Potassium | Calories: 0 kcal per gramJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA), 37th… regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026NoteUnlike aspartame (metabolised as amino acids, so it yields some energy), Ace-K is not metabolised by the human body at all — JECFA's absorption/distribution data show it passes through largely unchanged. Genuinely calorie-free, not merely negligible-at-use-levels. | Yes |
| Neotame | Calories: 0 kcal per gramUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteEffectively zero at use levels. Neotame is used in milligram quantities at 7,000-13,000x sweetness, so any caloric contribution is immeasurable in practice. No FDA per-gram caloric factor was located for it this pass (it does not appear in 21 CFR 101.9's polyol table, which covers sugar alcohols only and would not apply). Distinct from aspartame, which is metabolised as amino acids and so does yield energy, merely negligible in practice. | Yes |
| Advantame | Calories: 0 kcal per gramUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteEffectively zero at use levels — the most extreme case in this file, since advantame is used at roughly 1/20,000th the mass of sugar for equal sweetness. No FDA per-gram caloric factor was located this pass; 21 CFR 101.9's table covers sugar alcohols only and does not apply. | Yes |
| Tagatose | Calories: 1.5 kcal per gramUS FDA, Human Foods Program — signed Kyle Diamantas,… regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteENFORCEMENT DISCRETION, not a rule — the same footing as allulose's 0.4. FDA's letter of 21 November 2025 "recognizes D-tagatose's caloric value of 1.5 calories per gram" and says FDA will not object to its use when declaring calories. The figure is older than the letter: FDA said in 2022 it would not object to 1.5 kcal/g, and the GRN 977 notice traces it to a 1999 FDA labelling letter that this pass did not locate. THE EU DISAGREES BY A FACTOR OF TWO: EFSA concluded in November 2016 that the energy value for labelling is 3 kcal/g (as reported by the UK Food Standards Agency, fsa_rp1652; EFSA's own opinion was blocked). Whether the EU wrote that into law was not checked. Quote the authority with the number. | No |
| Maltitol | Calories: 2.1 kcal per gramElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteFDA's factor for crystalline maltitol, 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(F) — about half of sugar's 4. The EU uses one figure for all polyols except erythritol: 2.4 kcal/g (Reg 1169/2011 Annex XIV). MALTITOL SYRUP is not in FDA's table, and the regulation does not say whether a syrup takes maltitol's 2.1 or the 3.0 for hydrogenated starch hydrolysates; this record does not guess. Livesey's review puts maltitol's absorption, as glucose and sorbitol after hydrolysis, at roughly a third to a half of the dose. | No |
| Sorbitol | Calories: 2.6 kcal per gramElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteFDA's factor, 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(F): the highest of any single polyol in the table (hydrogenated starch hydrolysates, at 3.0, are a mixture), above xylitol 2.4 and maltitol 2.1. The EU uses 2.4 kcal/g for all polyols except erythritol (Reg 1169/2011 Annex XIV). | No |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Calories: 2 kcal per gramElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteNo inulin-specific factor: 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(C) says "A general factor of 2 calories per gram for soluble non-digestible carbohydrates shall be used." The EU's factor for fibre is also 2 kcal/g (Reg 1169/2011 Annex XIV). The energy comes from bacterial fermentation in the colon, not from glucose. Free sugars carried by the ingredient count at 4 kcal/g. | No |
| Yacon syrup | Calories: About 1.6-2.7 kcal per gram, depending on the batchManrique I, Párraga A, Hermann M; Centro Internacional de… reference checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: CIP develops and promotes yacon syrup processing; the manual also makes untested benefit claims (weight, caries), which this record does not use.NoteCIP's two syrup batches measured 164 and 265 kcal per 100 g, "el contenido de calorías puede variar fácilmente entre 164 y 265 kcal", and the difference tracks the FOS content. On a US label the FOS fraction would take 2 kcal/g (21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(C)) and the free sugars 4. A reduced-calorie syrup, not a calorie-free one. | Not a plain yes or no |
Not counted in Added Sugars (US label)
How this need is read. This need reads one yes-or-no fact: whether the sweetener counts in the Added Sugars line of a US Nutrition Facts panel. Yes here means it is not counted. Some of these rest on FDA enforcement discretion and not on a rule; the notes say which. This describes a labelling rule. It is not a statement about blood glucose.
- Yes: Erythritol, Allulose, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre).
- No: Sugar (sucrose), Yacon syrup.
- No sourced figure: Monk Fruit, Stevia, Xylitol, Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026 | Yes |
| Allulose | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoUS FDA, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteFollows Total Sugars, of which Added Sugars is a subset. Excluded from both the gram amount and the %DV. Enforcement discretion. | Yes |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | Counts in Added Sugars (US): YesCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteWhen added during processing or preparation. Sugars intrinsic to intact fruit and plain dairy are not Added Sugars. | No |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Neotame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Advantame | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Tagatose | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoUS FDA, Human Foods Program — signed Kyle Diamantas,… regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteSame letter, same discretion. Until late 2025 FDA's position was that "D-tagatose must be declared as an added sugar" (FDA, December 2023), so older labels can legitimately still show it there. | Yes |
| Maltitol | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026 | Yes |
| Sorbitol | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026 | Yes |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Counts in Added Sugars (US): NoElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteThe fructan, no; any free sugars the ingredient adds, yes. | Yes |
| Yacon syrup | Counts in Added Sugars (US): YesUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteSugars from syrups are added sugars. A jar sold as a single-ingredient syrup may instead use the treatment FDA gives "other pure sugars and syrups": no "Includes Xg Added Sugars" line, but the percent Daily Value still shown, with a footnote. Yacon is not named in that guidance; applying it here is our inference. Used as an ingredient in another food, its free sugars are added sugars in that food. | No |
No laxative warning label rule found (EU, UK, US)
How this need is read. This need reads the laxative warning label fact, which records what EU, UK and US labelling rules we found. Yes means the record says none was found in any of the three. No means at least one of them requires a statement in some circumstances; the cell says which and when. "None found" is an absence in the texts we opened, not a ruling that none is needed. A label rule is not a tolerance figure: each row also shows what the same record says about digestive tolerance, and a sweetener with no label rule can still cause symptoms.
- No rule found: Allulose, Inulin (chicory root fibre), Yacon syrup.
- Label rule found: Erythritol, Xylitol, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol.
- No sourced figure: Monk Fruit, Stevia, Sugar (sucrose), Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Laxative warning label: EU and UK: required above 10% added polyols, and on every table-top sweetener containing polyols. US: none foundEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, and current… regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU, Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4: "Foods containing more than 10 % added polyols authorised pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008" must carry "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects". Separately, with no threshold, Reg (EC) 1333/2008 Art 23(3)(a): "The labelling of a table-top sweetener containing polyols ... shall bear the following warnings: (a) polyols: 'excessive consumption may induce laxative effects'". Erythritol is one of those polyols: Reg (EU) 1129/2011 lists "E 968 Erythritol" in Group IV, Polyols, with sorbitol and maltitol (eu1129e). The rule applies to it exactly as to maltitol, sorbitol and xylitol; the 10% counts all added polyols in the food together. No exemption was found in the texts opened. Cargill applied for one, and EFSA (2023) concluded "the available data do not support the applicant's proposal for the exemption of erythritol" and that the warning "remains appropriate". Great Britain keeps both provisions unchanged in retained law. S.I. 2025/361 reg 23(1) keeps the E 968 authorisation in effect. US: none found in the texts opened, which were the eCFR search (erythritol appears only in 21 CFR 101.9 and 101.80) and FDA's letters for GRN 76, 208, 382, 401, 789 and 1296. The CFR laxative statements are ingredient-specific: sorbitol 50 g/day (184.1835(e)), mannitol 20 g/day (180.25(e)), polydextrose over 15 g per serving (172.841(e)). They apply to an erythritol blend containing those ingredients. Digestive tolerance, same record: 0.5–1 g/kg in one sitting · EU limit 0.5 g/kg per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026 NoteEFSA pooled NOAELs for diarrhoea from 10 human studies: range 0.51-1.0 g/kg bw, median 0.75. EFSA adopted the lower bound, 0.5 g/kg bw/day, as its first numerical ADI for erythritol (Dec 2023) and found children's 95th-percentile intake already exceeds it. | Label rule found |
| Allulose | Laxative warning label: None found in EU, UK or US rules; the EU/UK 10% polyol rule does not reach itEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, and GB… regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU/UK: the only general laxative statement, Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4 (same wording in the GB retained text), covers "Foods containing more than 10 % added polyols authorised pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008". It does not reach allulose. Annex I point 8 puts "all monosaccharides" under 'sugars' "but excludes polyols". Allulose is a monosaccharide, not a polyol, and is not an additive authorised under 1333/2008. There is also no Union-list entry that could carry a tagatose-style condition: allulose is absent from the adopted Reg (EU) 2017/2470 annex, EFSA could not establish its safety in 2025 (see eu_status), and a legislation.gov.uk search for "allulose" returns no results. Not opened: the current consolidated EU list (EUR-Lex bot-check) and the FSA's GB domestic list (retained 2015/2283 Art 3B, since S.I. 2025/361). US: eCFR has no section naming allulose or psicose. Its laxative statements are tied to single ingredients (172.841 polydextrose, 180.25 mannitol, 184.1835 sorbitol). FDA's 2020 allulose labelling guidance requires none. The GRN 693 letter and every later 'no questions' letter through GRN 1342 (19 Oct 2026) contain no laxative statement. This is an absence in the texts opened, not a ruling that none is needed. The lack of a mandatory warning says nothing about tolerance, which is lower than erythritol's (see tolerance: 0.4 g/kg in a single dose). Digestive tolerance, same record: 0.4 g/kg in one sitting · 0.9 g/kg per day · severe symptoms at 0.5 g/kgHan Y et al., Nutrients 10(12):2010 peer reviewed checked 30 Aug 2026 NoteHan 2018, two non-randomised dose-escalation experiments (n=30 and n=19), Korean adults aged 21-30 with BMI 18.5-23. Severe diarrhoea appeared at 0.5 g/kg single dose. The authors explicitly warn that "considerably more symptoms may appear in individuals who are old, obese, or with certain metabolic and GI diseases" and flag the small sample and a possibly inadequate one-week washout. Not a regulatory ADI — no authority has set one. | No rule found |
| Monk Fruit | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Stevia | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | Laxative warning label: EU and UK: required above 10% added polyols, and on every table-top sweetener containing polyols. US: none foundEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, via legislation.gov.uk) regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU, Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4: "Foods containing more than 10 % added polyols authorised pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008" must carry "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects". Xylitol (E 967, Group IV polyols) is one of those polyols, so the rule applies to it exactly as to erythritol, maltitol and sorbitol; the 10% counts all added polyols in the food together. Separately, with no threshold, Reg (EC) 1333/2008 Art 23(3)(a): "The labelling of a table-top sweetener containing polyols ... shall bear the following warnings: (a) polyols: 'excessive consumption may induce laxative effects'" (eu1333a23x). UK: the revised GB text of point 2.4 is word for word the same, the GB text of Art 23(3) is unchanged, and although SI 2025/361 omitted Annex II of 1333/2008 from 1 April 2025, its reg 23(1) keeps those authorisations in effect "as if it were an authorisation made under" the amended Regulation (uksi2025_361x). US: 21 CFR 172.395 says only that xylitol "may be safely used in foods for special dietary uses, provided the amount used is not greater than that required to produce its intended effect" and has no labelling paragraph. An eCFR search of Title 21 for "laxative" finds food label statements only for sorbitol (184.1835), mannitol (180.25) and polydextrose (172.841), none for xylitol. So none found in the texts opened; any such line on a US xylitol product is the maker's own choice. FDA GRAS letters were not opened. Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | Label rule found |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Aspartame | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Neotame | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Advantame | No sourced figure Digestive tolerance, same record: No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Tagatose | Laxative warning label: EU/UK: required above 15 g per serving, and in drinks above 1%. US: none foundEuropean Commission (text as adopted, via legislation.gov.uk) regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU wording, from the Union-list entry: "The labelling of any product where the level of D-Tagatose exceeds 15 g per serving and all beverages containing greater than 1 % D-Tagatose (as consumed) shall bear a statement 'excessive consumption may produce laxative effects'." This is a novel-food condition; the general EU rule for foods over 10% added polyols does not apply, because tagatose is a sugar, not a polyol. UK: the FSA/FSS assessment RP1652 (fsa_rp1652) says the 15 g per serving condition "was agreed for the EU and UK authorisation"; the GB domestic novel-food list itself was not opened. US: none found in the texts opened. Tagatose has no 21 CFR section: an eCFR search of Title 21 for "tagatose" finds only 101.80 (the dental-caries claim), and the eCFR "laxative" food label statements are only 172.841, 180.25 and 184.1835. FDA's GRN 977 letter (grn977_letter) contains no laxative statement; its labelling section covers only claims. The GRN 78 and 352 letters were not opened. Digestive tolerance, same record: GI effects from about 30 g in one sitting; EU/UK labels warn above 15 g per servingJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (INCHEM) regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026 NoteJECFA (2004): "ingestion of 30g or more of D-tagatose on a single occasion may cause gastrointestinal effects in humans" — a caution about use levels, NOT a recommended maximum, though the GRN 977 dossier paraphrases it as one. In a screening study of 73 healthy young men given about 30 g, nausea ran at 15.1% and diarrhoea at 31.5%, and flatulence did not settle over 15 days of 30 g a day (Buemann 1999); 20 g in chocolate did not significantly increase watery stools (Lee & Storey 1999); 75 g at once caused diarrhoea, nausea and/or flatulence in every subject (Donner 1999). In the EU and UK "a tolerable single dose of no more than 15 g D-tagatose per serving was agreed", and the novel-food authorisation requires "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects" on any product above 15 g per serving and on drinks above 1% tagatose. We found no US label requirement in the texts opened. FDA's own exposure estimate in GRN 977 puts the 90th-percentile US eater at 39.8 g a day — above the 30 g single-sitting caution if eaten at once. Most tolerance studies are abstract-only here and sit in a 1999 journal supplement of tagatose safety studies; sponsorship was not visible. | Label rule found |
| Maltitol | Laxative warning label: EU and UK: required above 10% added polyols, and on every table-top sweetener containing polyols. US: none foundEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, via legislation.gov.uk) regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU, Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4: "Foods containing more than 10 % added polyols authorised pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008" must carry "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects". Maltitol (E 965, Group IV polyols) is one of those polyols, exactly as erythritol, xylitol and sorbitol are; the 10% counts all added polyols in the food together. Separately, with no threshold, Reg (EC) 1333/2008 Art 23(3)(a): "The labelling of a table-top sweetener containing polyols ... shall bear the following warnings: (a) polyols: 'excessive consumption may induce laxative effects'" (eu1333a23m). UK: the current GB text of point 2.4 is word for word the same, and the GB text of Art 23(3) is unchanged (uk1169m). US: none found in the texts opened, which were the eCFR search of Title 21 for "maltitol" (21 CFR 101.9 and 101.80 only) and the eCFR search for "laxative" (food label statements only in 172.841 polydextrose, 180.25 mannitol and 184.1835 sorbitol). FDA's 1993-94 letters in the closed GRAS docket were not opened. Any such line on a US maltitol product is the maker's own choice. Digestive tolerance, same record: About 30 g in chocolate with no significant symptoms; diarrhoea from 20-45 g when taken in waterOku T, Hongo R, Nakamura S; Journal of Nutritional… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Maltitol was a gift from Towa Chemical Industry (a maltitol maker); partly funded by a Japanese government Grant-in-Aid. NoteIN CHOCOLATE (young adults, eaten as breakfast): 30 g caused no significant symptoms and 40 g only mild wind and gut noise, with no laxative effect at either dose ("Maltitol did not have any laxative effect when ingested at either 30 g (P = 0.32) or 40 g (P = 0.13) per day", Koutsou 1996, n=59; Storey 1998, n=20). IN WATER on an empty stomach (Japanese women, mean 52 kg): 22 of 27 got osmotic diarrhoea at doses between 20 and 45 g, and "No subject had osmotic diarrhea after the ingestion of 15 g of maltitol" (Oku 2008; maltitol donated by a manufacturer). SPREAD THROUGH THE DAY and raised until symptoms (n=12): mean threshold 93 g a day on maltitol against 113 g on sucrose, and no adaptation after 9 days of regular intake (Ruskone-Fourmestraux 2003). So the popular "maltitol chocolate gives everyone diarrhoea" overstates the controlled trials; a bolus on an empty stomach is a different matter. The chocolate studies are abstract-only here and their funding was not visible. | Label rule found |
| Sorbitol | Laxative warning label: US: required where daily intake may reach 50 g. EU and UK: required above 10% added polyols, and on every table-top sweetener containing polyolsElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteUS, 21 CFR 184.1835(e): "The label and labeling of food whose reasonably foreseeable consumption may result in a daily ingestion of 50 grams of sorbitol shall bear the statement: 'Excess consumption may have a laxative effect.'" EU, Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4: foods with "more than 10 % added polyols" must carry "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects". Sorbitol (E 420, Group IV polyols) is one of those polyols, exactly as erythritol, xylitol and maltitol are; the 10% counts all added polyols in the food together. Separately, with no threshold, Reg (EC) 1333/2008 Art 23(3)(a): "The labelling of a table-top sweetener containing polyols ... shall bear the following warnings: (a) polyols: 'excessive consumption may induce laxative effects'" (eu1333a23s). UK: the current GB text of point 2.4 is word for word the same, and the GB text of Art 23(3) is unchanged (uk1169s). The two triggers are not equivalent (a daily intake against a concentration), and the US one is 2.5 to 5 times the 10-20 g at which the trials found symptoms. Digestive tolerance, same record: Gas and bloating from about 10 g in one dose, severe symptoms at 20 g; malabsorption detectable from 5 gHyams JS; Gastroenterology 84(1):30-33 peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026 NoteHyams 1983 (n=7, breath hydrogen): "ingestion of as little as 5 g sorbitol was associated with a significant increase in breath hydrogen concentration. Most subjects experienced mild gastrointestinal distress (gas, bloating) after 10 g and severe symptoms (cramps, diarrhea) after 20 g." Jain 1985 (n=42, 10 g): clinical intolerance in 43% of white and 55% of non-white subjects; severe intolerance 32% against 4%. Yao 2014 (Monash, double-blind, 10 g): only 33% of healthy subjects and 40% of people with IBS absorbed it completely, and symptoms rose significantly in the IBS group only, "independent of malabsorption". MEDICINES: the EMA keeps an adult laxative-warning threshold of 10 g and proposes 140 mg/kg a day ("equivalent of 10 g/70 kg"), noting children can be more sensitive. All three trials are single doses in solution on an empty stomach; nothing opened measured sorbitol eaten with food through the day. | Label rule found |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Laxative warning label: None found in EU, UK or US rulesEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, via legislation.gov.uk) regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteThe EU laxative statement applies to foods with "more than 10 % added polyols" (Reg 1169/2011 Annex III 2.4); inulin is not a polyol. The current UK text of point 2.4 is word for word the same (uk1169i). US: none found in the texts opened: no 21 CFR section affirms inulin as GRAS, and the eCFR "laxative" food statements are only 172.841, 180.25 and 184.1835. An absence in the texts opened, not a ruling that none is needed. Digestive tolerance, same record: Inulin: up to about 5 g a day for no more than mild flatulence. Oligofructose: 10 g in one dose caused substantial symptomsMysonhimer AR, Holscher HD; Advances in Nutrition 13(6):2237-2276 peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Publication fees paid by the IAFNS Carbohydrate Committee (industry-pooled). "HDH has received grant funding from Danone, Tate & Lyle, General Mills, and speaking honoraria from Beneo and the Calorie Control Council." NoteREVIEW (Mysonhimer & Holscher 2022, 17 inulin and 17 FOS trials in adults): "Low doses of 0.75–5 g/d inulin led to only mild flatulence, medium doses of 7.5–20 g/d led to mild and moderate symptoms, and higher doses (≥22 g/d) resulted in study dropouts"; for oligofructose or FOS, "a reasonable recommendation to avoid intolerance symptoms is 7.8 g/d". Publication fees were paid by an industry-pooled committee, and one author has grants from food companies and honoraria from Beneo. TRIAL (Bonnema 2010, n=26, Cargill-funded): "Doses up to 10 g/day of native inulin and up to 5 g/day of oligofructose were well-tolerated in healthy, young adults"; "The 10-g dose of oligofructose substantially increased GI symptoms". Shorter chains are harder on the gut. The EU bowel-function claim needs 12 g a day, above the review's 5 g comfort level. | No rule found |
| Yacon syrup | Laxative warning label: None found: not a polyol, so the EU/UK 10% polyol rule misses it. US: none foundEuropean Parliament and Council (text as adopted, via legislation.gov.uk) regulatory checked 3 Nov 2026NoteEU and UK: Reg (EU) 1169/2011 Annex III point 2.4 (adopted text, and the current UK retained text, which is the same) requires "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects" only for "Foods containing more than 10 % added polyols authorised pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008". Yacon syrup's FOS are fructans, not polyols, and no other Annex III entry covers FOS or fibre. A yacon product blended with more than 10% added polyols (erythritol, maltitol, sorbitol, xylitol or any other Group IV polyol) does need the statement, because of the polyol. US: an eCFR search of Title 21 for "laxative effect" finds food statements only for sorbitol (184.1835(e)), mannitol (180.25(e)) and polydextrose (172.841). Searches for yacon, fructooligosaccharide(s) and oligofructose return 0 results, and FDA's GRN 1271 scFOS letter raises only claims. This is an absence in the texts opened, not a ruling that none is needed. The EUR-Lex consolidated text could not be opened. Digestive tolerance, same record: About 10 g FOS a day tolerated; about 20 g FOS a day caused intolerable symptoms. How much syrup that is depends on its FOS contentGenta S, Cabrera W, Habib N, Pons J, Manrique… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "This research was supported by CONICET, CIUNT, ANPCyT (Argentina) and International Potato Center (Peru) grants"; co-author Manrique is CIP staff, and CIP made the syrup. Declared: "There are no conflict of interests." NoteGenta 2009, 120 days: 0.14 g FOS/kg a day "went through the whole experimental period with no difficulties", while 20 g FOS/70 kg a day caused diarrhoea, severe distension, flatulence and nausea: "The subjects considered the flatulence severe and unacceptable and no adaptation in symptoms occurred over time". At Genta's 41% FOS, 10 g FOS is about 24 g of syrup; at 22% FOS (the syrup used in most later trials) it is about 45 g. Shorter trials: 20 g syrup a day (6.4 g FOS) was "well tolerated" (Geyer 2008, n=16, with a CIP co-author). | No rule found |
A numeric ADI has been set
How this need is read. This need reads the acceptable daily intake fact. Yes means the record holds a number, and the cell names whose it is: for several sweeteners the FDA, EFSA and JECFA figures differ, and this need does not ask whether they agree. A record that holds an ADI status in words, such as "not specified", is shown as not a plain yes or no. This need says only whether a number has been set. It does not say that a sweetener with a number is safer than one without, or the reverse.
- Yes: Erythritol, Stevia, Sucralose, Aspartame, Saccharin, Acesulfame Potassium, Neotame, Advantame.
- Not a plain yes or no: Monk Fruit, Tagatose, Maltitol, Sorbitol.
- No sourced figure: Allulose, Sugar (sucrose), Xylitol, Inulin (chicory root fibre), Yacon syrup.
| Sweetener | What our record says | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Acceptable daily intake: EU 0.5 g per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteEFSA pooled NOAELs for diarrhoea from 10 human studies: range 0.51-1.0 g/kg bw, median 0.75. EFSA adopted the lower bound, 0.5 g/kg bw/day, as its first numerical ADI for erythritol (Dec 2023) and found children's 95th-percentile intake already exceeds it. | Yes |
| Allulose | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Monk Fruit | Acceptable daily intake: Temporary ADI 0-10 mg/kg bw/day, as mogroside V (JECFA, 2026)JECFA (FAO/WHO) regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteJECFA, 102nd meeting (2026): "The Committee established a temporary ADI of 0-10 mg/kg bw per day, expressed as mogroside V, based on a NOAEL of 2144 mg/kg bw per day for mogroside V, the highest dose tested in a 52-week rat study and the application of a 200-fold uncertainty factor." In the same evaluation JECFA took a conservative estimate of the highest dietary exposure for children, 38 mg/kg bw/day, and concluded it "exceeds the temporary ADI by approximately four-fold, which would pose a potential safety concern under the proposed uses and proposed maximum levels". JECFA noted that estimate rests on proposed Codex (GSFA) food categories and maximum levels, not on measured intakes; FDA's modelling for US use (GRN 706, see dietary_exposure_mg_per_kg_day) is far lower, a 1.52 mg/kg bw/day mean for diabetic children. To complete the evaluation JECFA requires, by the end of 2029, a reproductive toxicity study that evaluates the reproductive capacity of the F1 generation, and revised proposed uses and maximum levels. History: JECFA put monk fruit extract on its 2016 agenda and removed it because no data were submitted; EFSA (2019) could not set an ADI because the toxicity database was insufficient (see safety_signal). | Not a plain yes or no |
| Stevia | Acceptable daily intake: 4 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteExpressed as STEVIOL EQUIVALENTS, not as grams of product — a conversion step every formulator has to do and many skip. Set by JECFA at its 69th meeting in 2008 (corrected 2026-08-31 from an earlier "2009" taken second-hand; the JECFA database itself says 2008, when the temporary designation was removed) on a NOEL of 970 mg/kg bw/day from a long-term stevioside study with a 100-fold safety factor, and independently by EFSA in 2010 from a 2-year rat carcinogenicity study. In November 2024 EFSA assessed an applicant request to raise it to 6 or 16 mg/kg bw/day and refused: "there is insufficient justification to increase the current ADI." | Yes |
| Sugar (sucrose) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Sucralose | Acceptable daily intake: FDA 5 · EFSA 15 · JECFA 15 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteFDA sets 5 mg/kg bw/day; EFSA and JECFA both sit at 15. EFSA re-confirmed 15 in its re-evaluation adopted 10 December 2025, from a BMDL reference point of 55 mg/kg bw/day, and found no safety concern for genotoxicity of sucralose or its impurities and degradation products. Never state "the ADI for sucralose" without naming whose. | Yes |
| Aspartame | Acceptable daily intake: FDA 50 · JECFA 40 · EFSA 40 mg per kg body weight per dayWorld Health Organization, jointly with IARC and the WHO/FAO… regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026NoteFDA sets 50 mg/kg bw/day; JECFA and EFSA both sit at 40. Never state "the ADI for aspartame" without naming whose. Origin, per FDA's own timeline: JECFA established 40 mg/kg bw/day in April 1981. FDA set its own ADI at 50 mg/kg bw/day in July 1983, explicitly "because of its review of the use of aspartame in carbonated beverages" — not a from-scratch alternative risk assessment, a beverage-category-specific figure that has stood since. EFSA's 2013 re-evaluation independently confirmed 40 mg/kg bw/day "is protective for the general population", and EFSA confirmed 40 again in September 2026 (see eu_status). For a 70 kg adult drinking cans containing 200-300 mg aspartame each, JECFA/WHO's own worked example puts the ADI at more than 9-14 cans/day — the practical margin is large under any of the three figures. | Yes |
| Saccharin | Acceptable daily intake: JECFA 9 · EFSA 9 · FDA 15 mg per kg body weight per dayWHO/FAO Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives, via IPCS… regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteJECFA and EFSA both currently sit at 9 mg/kg bw/day (2024, see eu_status) — a genuinely unstable figure across JECFA's own history, not a settled number that just happened to be revised once: an early unconditional ADI of "0-15 mg/kg bw" (dietetic purposes only) was cut to a temporary "0-2.5 mg/kg bw" at JECFA's 21st meeting (1977, at the height of the cancer scare) and extended provisionally through 1980, later settled at 5 mg/kg bw/day (Scientific Committee on Food, 1995), and only reached the current 9 mg/kg bw/day in 2024. FDA's figure of 15 mg/kg bw/day is now PRIMARY-VERIFIED and this gap is CLOSED (2026-09-01). The earlier pass could not reach FDA.gov and correctly declined to treat a sibling session's narrative report as verification, asking a future session to open the document directly and give it a real source entry. Done: FDA's "Safe Levels of Sweeteners" chart (fdasafelevels, below) states "Saccharin is 15 mg/kg bw/d" in its own ADI notes. Worth flagging rather than hiding: 15 mg/kg bw/day is suspiciously close to JECFA's own long-superseded "0-15" early figure, which raises the possibility FDA's number traces to that same original 1970s-era assessment rather than an independent current one — NOT confirmed, a hypothesis for a future session with FDA.gov access to check. Never state "the ADI for saccharin" without naming whose. | Yes |
| Acesulfame Potassium | Acceptable daily intake: FDA 15 · JECFA 15 · EFSA 15 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 23 Oct 2026NoteUNLIKE aspartame and sucralose, all three bodies now agree — but only because two of them moved to meet the third, worth stating rather than presenting as if they always agreed. FDA set 15 mg/kg bw/day from its FIRST approval in 1988, deriving it directly: from the highest dose tested in a long-term rat study (3% acesulfame K in the diet) using "a 100-fold safety factor," concluding "the acceptable daily intake in 15 milligrams per kilogram body weight." JECFA independently reached the same 15 at its 37th meeting (Geneva, June 1990, WHO Food Additives Series 28) — but only after RAISING its own earlier ADI of 9 mg/kg bw/day (set at the 25th/27th meetings on a 2-year dog study), once the newer rat study's higher NOEL of 1500 mg/kg bw/day became available. The EU followed last and slowest: the SCF also set 9 mg/kg bw/day originally, and EFSA did not move it to 15 until its 2025 re-evaluation — a 35-year gap during which the EU figure was the outlier. | Yes |
| Neotame | Acceptable daily intake: FDA 0.3 · JECFA 2 · EFSA 10 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteTHE WIDEST REGULATOR-TO-REGULATOR SPREAD IN THIS FILE: 33-fold between FDA (0.3) and EFSA (10), with JECFA (2) in between. For comparison, sucralose spans 3-fold and aspartame 1.25-fold. The divergence is traceable, not arbitrary. JECFA set 0-2 mg/kg bw at its 61st meeting (2003) from a NOEL of 200 mg/kg bw/day in a 1-year dog study with a 100-fold safety factor. EFSA held the same 2 mg/kg bw/day from 2007 until July 2025, when its re-evaluation RAISED IT FIVE-FOLD to 10 mg/kg bw/day — the old figure had rested on that dog study's finding of increased serum alkaline phosphatase, and the Panel concluded this "was not a marker of adverse effect in the absence of accompanying liver toxicity," moving the reference point to a NOAEL of 1000 mg/kg bw/day from 52-week chronic and 104-week carcinogenicity studies in rats, 100-fold uncertainty factor. FDA's 0.3 mg/kg bw/day is the outlier low end and this file has NOT located FDA's own derivation for it — the figure is taken from FDA's own "Safe Levels of Sweeteners" chart, which states it without showing the underlying study. Worth a future session: FDA is MORE conservative than JECFA on neotame by ~6.7x while being MORE permissive than JECFA on advantame by ~6.6x (see that record) — the same agency, the same two structurally-related sweeteners, diverging in opposite directions by almost the same factor. Not explained here; flagged as genuinely odd rather than smoothed over. | Yes |
| Advantame | Acceptable daily intake: FDA 32.8 · JECFA 5 · EFSA 5 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added… regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteFDA sets 32.8 mg/kg bw/day; JECFA and EFSA both sit at 5 — FDA roughly 6.6x MORE PERMISSIVE. Note the inversion against neotame, where FDA is ~6.7x more CONSERVATIVE than JECFA (0.3 vs 2). Same agency, two aspartame derivatives, opposite directions, almost the same factor. Nothing found this pass explains it; recorded as a genuine oddity rather than smoothed away. EFSA's derivation is documented: ADI 5 mg/kg bw/day from a 100-fold uncertainty factor on a NOAEL of 500 mg/kg bw/day for maternal toxicity (gastrointestinal disturbance) in a prenatal developmental toxicity study in the rabbit. JECFA independently arrived at 0-5 mg/kg bw at its 77th meeting (2013) and re-affirmed the same figure at its 80th (2015). FDA's 32.8 figure comes from its own consumer chart, which states it without showing a derivation — the same gap this file records for FDA's neotame figure. | Yes |
| Tagatose | Acceptable daily intake: JECFA: not specified (2004). No EU ADI; authorised as a novel food with no maximum levelsJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (INCHEM) regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteA history worth knowing, because tagatose is one of the few sweeteners JECFA once refused. 2000: NO ADI, "because of concern about the potential of D-tagatose to induce glycogen deposition and hypertrophy in the liver and to increase the concentrations of uric acid in serum". 2001: 0-80 mg/kg bw, from a human no-effect level of 15 g three times a day. 2003: temporary 0-125. 2004: "not specified", once two-year rat histopathology was in. JECFA attached two conditions: the 30 g single-occasion GI caution (see tolerance), and that the ADI "does not apply to individuals with hereditary fructose intolerance" — anyone with that diagnosis should treat tagatose as they treat fructose. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Maltitol | Acceptable daily intake: JECFA: not specified (maltitol 1993, maltitol syrup 1997). EFSA re-evaluation of E 965 still ongoingJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (INCHEM mirror… regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteJECFA gave maltitol of at least 98% purity an ADI "not specified" in 1988 and confirmed it at its 41st meeting (1993) after a rat carcinogenicity study; maltitol syrup was last evaluated in 1997 (49th meeting). The WHO database page labels the 1993 entry "Meeting: 46", which matches the 1996 specifications, not the evaluation. EFSA's sweeteners page (reviewed 27 October 2026) lists "E 965 Maltitols — Re-evaluation ongoing"; of the polyols only erythritol has been finished (2023). Claims of a "2019 EFSA re-evaluation of maltitol" on consumer sites are contradicted by EFSA's own page. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Sorbitol | Acceptable daily intake: JECFA: not specified (1982); sorbitol syrup, no ADI allocated (1988). EFSA re-evaluation of E 420 still ongoingJoint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (INCHEM mirror… regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteJECFA set sorbitol's ADI "not specified" at its 26th meeting (1982, TRS 683); the specification monograph adds that "No ADI was allocated at the 33rd JECFA (1988)" for sorbitol syrup. EFSA's sweeteners page (reviewed 27 October 2026) lists "E 420 Sorbitols — Re-evaluation ongoing"; EFSA's July 2026 plenary update says the exposure assessment for the polyols "will start early 2027". The EU deadline for re-evaluating sweeteners was 2020. | Not a plain yes or no |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
| Yacon syrup | No sourced figure | No sourced figure |
If you are managing diabetes
A sugar substitute cannot treat a low blood glucose
Low blood glucose is below 70 mg/dL. The ADA's stated rule is 15 grams of FAST-ACTING carbohydrate, then recheck after 15 minutes — none of the substitutes on this site qualify, because not raising blood glucose is the entire point of them. Severe hypoglycaemia is an emergency needing help from others; if someone is unconscious and glucagon is unavailable or nobody knows how to use it, call 911. Your own care plan takes priority over anything written here.
American Diabetes Association clinical guidance checked 31 Aug 2026This section does not sort sweeteners into suitable and unsuitable for diabetes, and no need on this page is called "does not raise blood glucose". Our records hold a measured glycaemic index for 4 of 17 sweeteners and a description in words for others. Turning either into a yes or no would be our judgement, not a sourced fact, so the table shows what each record says, as stored.
It describes the ingredient, not a retail product, which is often mostly something else by weight. Your own care plan takes priority over anything on this page. Do not change a dose based on anything you read here.
| Sweetener | Blood glucose in our record | If you're managing diabetes |
|---|---|---|
| Erythritol | Glycemic index: 0 (glucose = 100)Livesey G, Nutrition Research Reviews 16:163-191 peer reviewed checked 29 Aug 2026NoteMean 0, SD 17 across 4 studies (glucose = 100). Insulinaemic index 2. The SD is large relative to the mean: this is "no detectable effect", not a precise zero. | Does not move blood glucose by any figure in this record — but the digestive tolerance ceiling is closer than it looks, and diabetes is the exact variable that weakens the strongest cardiovascular signal.Heianza Y, Sun Q, Manson JE et al.; European… peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026Declared interest: Three authors hold equity or executive positions at Sapient Bioanalytics, the metabolomics company; one holds an NIH grant. Declared and displayed.NoteGlycaemic index 0, subtracts in full from net carbs — nothing here requires carbohydrate coverage. The tolerance figure above is the one to watch: a single 30 g serving is about 86% of the EU daily limit for a 70 kg adult (see this record's verdict caveat). Separately, and worth knowing rather than reassuring: in the Nurses' Health Study, erythritol's association with coronary heart disease attenuated to non-significance specifically once diabetes was added to the statistical model — while the same-magnitude signal for mannitol and sorbitol, eaten at nowhere near erythritol's scale, stayed significant. That does not clear erythritol; it means diabetes status is the specific variable behind whether the strongest available human evidence for a heart-risk association survives adjustment, in a population managing a condition that already elevates cardiovascular risk on its own. |
| Allulose | Glycemic response: Negligible; no established GI value — reduces POSTPRANDIAL glucose and insulin (moderate certainty), but no significant effect on HbA1c, fasting glucose/insulin, lipids, uric acid or body compositionOsborn L, DuPuis K, Liu S, Della Corte D,… peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteUPDATED 2026-08-31 with the field's current best synthesis, previously flagged in this backlog as bot-blocked — it is Open Access and loads cleanly in a real browser; only automated fetchers (WebFetch, server curl) were gated, the same JS bot-check pattern already on file for EUR-Lex and the ADA Standards of Care. Osborn, DuPuis, Liu, Della Corte & Della Corte 2026 (AJCN 123(6):101314) is a PROSPERO-registered (CRD42024567433) systematic review and meta-analysis of 20 controlled human intervention trials (12 allulose, 8 tagatose; 1,033 participants total), searched through 30 April 2025 — broader than either single study previously cited here. ALLULOSE ARM: significantly reduced postprandial glucose (incremental AUC SMD -0.66, 95% CI -0.92 to -0.39, moderate certainty) and postprandial insulin (SMD -1.27, 95% CI -2.14 to -0.40, moderate certainty) — but NO significant pooled effect on HbA1c, fasting glucose, fasting insulin, blood lipids, uric acid, or body composition (very low to moderate certainty across those outcomes). Read the postprandial finding and the null findings together: the acute glucose/insulin-blunting effect this record has documented since Tani 2023 holds up under a larger, more rigorous synthesis, but it does not extend to weight, fasting markers or long-term glycaemic control on the evidence gathered so far — allulose blunts a spike, it has not been shown to improve the numbers that matter for longer-run metabolic health. No third-party funding; the review's only disclosed conflict (SL) is unrelated consulting/editorial work with no rare-sugar-industry tie, a materially cleaner disclosure than tani2023's Kagawa University rare-sugar-group authorship (still flagged on that source below). Tani 2023 (145 participants/group, healthy adults, mechanism-establishing) and Ayesh 2024 (126 people with type 2 diabetes, first T2D-specific signal) remain cited in full below as the specific studies this broader 2026 synthesis draws on and updates, not as duplicated or superseded claims. | The only sweetener in this file with its own clinical trial data in people with type 2 diabetes — a real signal, still small, and the digestive ceiling is tighter than erythritol's.Ayesh H, Suhail S, Ayesh S; Metabolism Open 24:100329 peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteAyesh et al. 2024 (6 RCTs, 126 people with diagnosed type 2 diabetes, 5-8.5 g per meal) found a significant reduction in glucose AUC and in continuous-glucose-monitor time-above-range; fasting glucose and time-in-range did not reach significance. That sits alongside Tani 2023's larger healthy-adult AUC-reduction finding, not in place of it — see glycemic_response above. Net carbs subtract in full and the glycaemic/insulinaemic response is negligible per FDA. The caution: allulose's single-dose tolerance ceiling (0.4 g/kg bw, about 28 g for a 70 kg adult) is LOWER than erythritol's, not higher, and severe diarrhoea appeared at 0.5 g/kg in the dosing study — worth knowing before treating it as the gentler option at typical sugar-replacement quantities. |
| Monk Fruit | Glycemic response: No meaningful glucose or insulin spike in healthy adults, acutelyTey SL, Salleh NB, Henry J, Forde CG; International… peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteTey et al. 2017, the only published human RCT of monk fruit sweetener itself (as opposed to its regulatory toxicology). 30 healthy men, randomised crossover, four 65 g-sucrose-equivalent preloads (aspartame, monk fruit, stevia, sucrose). Monk fruit, stevia and aspartame all produced significantly lower postprandial glucose and insulin than sucrose, with no meaningful spike above baseline for any of the three. THE MORE INTERESTING FINDING: ad libitum lunch intake after the non-nutritive-sweetener preloads was significantly HIGHER than after sucrose — compensatory eating largely offset the calories saved at the preload, leaving total daily energy intake unchanged across all four arms. Read as evidence about the preload only, not as evidence the sweetener itself changes appetite regulation days or weeks out — one meal, one measurement. | No published trial has tested monk fruit sweetener in people with diabetes specifically — despite diabetic children showing the highest modelled exposure of any group FDA looked at.US FDA, Office of Food Additive Safety regulatory checked 31 Aug 2026NoteFDA's own exposure modelling in GRN 706 found diabetic children carry the highest mean mogroside V intake of any subgroup assessed (1.52 mg/kg bw/day, against 0.58 for healthy adults) — the population already consuming it most is exactly the one with no dedicated clinical trial behind it. The only human RCT of the sweetener itself (Tey 2017) tested 30 healthy men, not people with diabetes, and found no meaningful glucose or insulin spike from monk fruit, stevia or aspartame versus sucrose. Two things this record already flags matter more here than usual: the only ADI is JECFA's temporary 2026 one, which JECFA's conservative estimate of children's exposure under proposed Codex uses exceeds about four-fold (see adi_status), and what you buy in a tub is usually mostly a bulking agent by weight, very often erythritol — read that record's diabetes note for what you're actually eating in bulk. |
| Stevia | Glycemic response: Low-certainty evidence of reduced fasting glucose, strongest under 120 days of useZare M, Zeinalabedini M, Ebrahimpour-Koujan S, Bellissimo N, Azadbakht… peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteZare et al. 2024, meta-analysis of 26 RCTs, 1,439 participants (PROSPERO CRD42023414411). Stevia supplementation significantly reduced fasting glucose, with the effect most consistent in trials shorter than 120 days and in participants with higher BMI, diabetes or hypertension. NO significant effect on insulin concentration or HbA1c — the fasting-glucose finding does not generalise to those two measures. Authors rate the overall certainty of evidence LOW and call for more RCTs at higher stevia doses. Read alongside health_claim_status below: a real, specific, but modest and short-duration signal — not evidence of durable metabolic benefit. | The strongest direct glucose evidence in this file — Zare et al. 2024 found the fasting-glucose-lowering effect more pronounced specifically in people with diabetes — but it did not move HbA1c, and the certainty is rated low.Zare M, Zeinalabedini M, Ebrahimpour-Koujan S, Bellissimo N, Azadbakht… peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteZare et al. 2024 (26 RCTs, 1,439 participants) found stevia supplementation significantly reduced fasting glucose, with the effect most consistent in trials under 120 days and among participants with higher BMI, diabetes or hypertension specifically. No significant effect on insulin or HbA1c — the fasting-glucose finding does not extend to either. The authors rate the overall evidence certainty LOW and call for more RCTs at higher doses. Read alongside health_claim_status above: this is evidence of a real, specific, short-duration signal, not of a durable independent metabolic benefit — the well-supported claim remains that stevia lets you replace sugar, not that it treats diabetes on its own. |
| Sugar (sucrose) | Glycemic index: 65 (glucose = 100)Livesey G; Nutrition Research Reviews 16(2):163-191 peer reviewed checked 30 Aug 2026NoteGlucose = 100. Sucrose is a glucose-fructose disaccharide, so only about half of it is glucose on hydrolysis — which is why its GI sits below pure glucose rather than at it. | The baseline every other record in this file is measured against — glycaemic index 65, counts in full as carbohydrate, no substitution question to weigh.Livesey G; Nutrition Research Reviews 16(2):163-191 peer reviewed checked 31 Aug 2026NoteSucrose raises blood glucose predictably and substantially and counts in full toward Total Carbohydrate and Total Sugars — standard carbohydrate counting applies exactly as your care team already teaches, with no arithmetic adjustment and no guardrail exception. It is the reference point this entire site is built against: every claim made about a substitute elsewhere in this file is, underneath, a claim about how far that substitute departs from what sugar does here. |
| Xylitol | No sourced figure | No sourced glycaemic index exists for xylitol, so this record counts half its carbohydrate rather than risk under-reporting to a reader managing diabetes.Cornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 31 Aug 2026NoteAt 2.4 kcal/g xylitol carries real metabolisable energy, unlike erythritol's 0 — and because no fetched source gives xylitol a glycaemic index, net_carb_treatment above deliberately takes the conservative subtract_half assignment rather than assume a glucose-neutrality nobody has measured. The cardiovascular association (CLSA/EPIC-Norfolk, conference-stage) carries the same causation caveats as erythritol's, for the same reasons. If there is a dog in the household, the hazard above applies regardless of anyone's own diabetes management — onset can be 10 to 60 minutes. |
| Sucralose | No sourced figure | Net-zero at the pure compound — but the packet in your hand is mostly dextrose or maltodextrin, ordinary fast-digesting carbohydrate, not sucralose.US Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 31 Aug 2026NoteSucralose itself is used at milligram levels and subtracts in full from net carbs, with no dedicated glucose or insulin outcome trial behind it in this record — the only related human data (natmetab2025) measured acute hunger and hypothalamic blood flow, not glycaemic response. What matters more for dosing: retail tabletop packets and cup-for-cup blends are bulked with dextrose or maltodextrin, both ordinary rapidly-digested carbohydrate. A sucralose packet is not a zero-carbohydrate product — the sucralose in it is; count the bulking agent's grams as real carbohydrate. |
| Aspartame | No sourced figure | Net-zero at the pure compound and no dedicated glucose or insulin trial behind that in this record — the number to actually watch for is Total Carbohydrate from whatever aspartame is dissolved or mixed into, not aspartame itself.US Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 31 Aug 2026NoteAspartame subtracts in full from net carbs at the tiny amounts actually used (see net_carb_treatment and caloric_contribution above), so it does not meaningfully move blood glucose on its own. It is not a special case for diabetes management beyond the general cautions this site applies to every high-intensity sweetener: tabletop packets are commonly bulked with dextrose or maltodextrin (ordinary fast carbohydrate — count that, not the aspartame), and nothing in this record establishes a glycaemic or metabolic benefit from choosing aspartame specifically, only that it does not itself add carbohydrate at use levels. The one genuinely diabetes-adjacent nuance in this record is unrelated to glucose: pregnant PKU carriers were specifically modelled at the ADI and found not to be at fetal risk from aspartame's phenylalanine — worth knowing if PKU screening and diabetes management ever intersect for a reader, but not a glycaemic finding. |
| Saccharin | No sourced figure | Non-nutritive and net-zero at the pure compound, with the longest track record of any sweetener in this file — but watch the carrier, not the saccharin, and expect a bitter aftertaste at higher concentrations that many blended products exist specifically to mask.Cornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteSaccharin is not metabolised as an energy source (see calories_per_g_us) and subtracts in full from net carbs at the milligram amounts actually used — it does not itself move blood glucose. As with every other high-intensity sweetener in this file, the practical caution is the carrier: tabletop packets are bulked with dextrose, ordinary fast carbohydrate, which is what actually needs counting. Nothing in this record establishes a glycaemic benefit specific to choosing saccharin over another high-intensity sweetener — only that, like the others, it does not itself add carbohydrate at use levels. |
| Acesulfame Potassium | No sourced figure | Genuinely calorie- and carbohydrate-free at the pure compound, with no dedicated glucose or insulin trial in this record — but Ace-K is almost never used alone, so the product it comes in matters more than the fact itself.US Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteUnlike aspartame, Ace-K is not even metabolised by the body (see calories_per_g_us) — there is no amino-acid caloric value hiding behind the "negligible at use levels" framing this site uses for other high-intensity sweeteners. That makes the pure compound the cleanest net-carb case in this file. What actually matters for a reader managing diabetes is that Ace-K is almost always found blended with aspartame or another sweetener specifically because of its heat stability and shelf-life (see heat_stability) — so the product's Total Carbohydrate is set by whatever else is in the formulation, not by the Ace-K. This record does not establish any glycaemic benefit or harm from Ace-K itself; the open question documented above (carcinogenicity_evidence) is about long-term cancer association, not blood glucose. |
| Neotame | No sourced figure | No carbohydrate and no glucose effect at use levels — but as with every high-intensity sweetener here, the packet is almost entirely bulking agent, and that is what to count.US Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteNeotame is used in milligrams and subtracts in full from net carbs (see net_carb_treatment above). This record contains no dedicated glucose, insulin or HbA1c trial for neotame, so it establishes only that neotame itself adds no carbohydrate — not that it confers any metabolic benefit. Practical consequence identical to sucralose and aspartame in this file: judge a tabletop product by its carrier (commonly dextrose or maltodextrin, ordinary fast-digesting carbohydrate), not by the sweetener named on the front. |
| Advantame | No sourced figure | No carbohydrate and no glucose effect at use levels — and at 20,000x sucrose, the sweetener is a rounding error in any product; the carrier is the entire carbohydrate question.EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added… regulatory checked 1 Sep 2026NoteAdvantame is used at sub-milligram levels and subtracts in full from net carbs. This record contains no dedicated glucose, insulin or HbA1c trial, so it establishes only that advantame itself adds no carbohydrate — not any metabolic benefit. One relevant detail from EFSA's assessment: advantame "was well tolerated in single or repeated doses up to 0.5 mg/kg bw/day by normo-glycemic or diabetic subjects" — a tolerability observation in people with diabetes, not an efficacy or glycaemic-benefit finding, and it should not be reported as one. |
| Tagatose | Glycemic response: No rise from tagatose alone; lowers the postprandial response to other carbohydrate; small pooled HbA1c reduction (-0.25 points), leaning on industry-run trialsOsborn L, DuPuis K, Liu S, Della Corte D,… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026NoteOsborn et al. 2026 (AJCN; PROSPERO CRD42024567433; the same review session 14 used for allulose): across 8 tagatose trials, postprandial glucose SMD -1.03 (-1.36 to -0.71) and insulin SMD -1.05 (-1.61 to -0.49), both moderate certainty; HbA1c mean difference -0.25 (-0.44 to -0.06), moderate certainty — the one long-run marker where tagatose beat allulose, which showed no HbA1c effect in the same review; fasting insulin lower at very low certainty; "No other significant pooled effects". Abstract only — the tagatose trial list, and therefore how much weight the next study carries in the pool, was not seen. READ THE LARGEST TRIAL WITH ITS CONFLICT: Ensor 2015 (phase 3, 494 randomised, people with type 2 diabetes not on glucose-lowering drugs, 15 g three times a day for 10 months) was "supported in part by the Biospherics subsidiary of Spherix Incorporated", the company developing tagatose as a diabetes drug, and its corresponding author "was president of Spherix at the time the clinical data were collected". Much of its placebo-adjusted effect is HbA1c RISING in the placebo arm (US subgroup at month 10: tagatose -0.07, placebo +0.37). The only independent long-term study found, a 12-month uncontrolled pilot (Donner 2010, n=8 completers), saw HbA1c fall from 10.6% to 9.6%, NOT significant (p=0.08), with GI side effects in 10 of 12 recruited. FDA's 2025 letter "acknowledges the different effect D-tagatose has on glycemic response in certain studies" — a regulator acknowledging studies, not an efficacy finding. | Does not raise glucose on its own and may blunt the rise from other carbohydrate — but it is partly absorbed, so this record counts half its grams, and the HbA1c benefit leans on industry-run trials.Osborn L, DuPuis K, Liu S, Della Corte D,… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026NoteThe pooled HbA1c reduction (-0.25 points, moderate certainty, Osborn 2026) is real but small, and the largest trial behind it was sponsored by the company developing tagatose as a diabetes drug, with much of its effect coming from HbA1c rising in the placebo arm. The one independent 12-month pilot did not reach significance. Net carbs: up to 81% may be absorbed in the small bowel and it carries 1.5 (FDA) to 3 (EFSA) kcal/g, so the conservative half-count applies. On a US label printed after November 2025 it may no longer appear under Total Sugars or Added Sugars, but it is still in Total Carbohydrate. Tolerance: 30 g in one sitting is where GI symptoms become common. A gout or high uric acid history is worth mentioning to a clinician before regular use; hereditary fructose intolerance rules it out. |
| Maltitol | Glycemic index: 35 (glucose = 100)Livesey G, Nutrition Research Reviews 16(2):163-191 peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "This analysis and review was commissioned by the European Polyol Association, to whom the author is grateful for support." The author ran a nutrition consultancy (Independent Nutrition Logic). It is also the source of every polyol GI in this file (see erythritol's livesey2003).NotePooled from 9 studies, SD 9 (Livesey 2003, Table 5; the text gives SD 7 — the table is cited). Insulinaemic index 27. SYRUPS RUN HIGHER: high-maltitol syrup 48, intermediate 53, regular 52, high-polymer 36 (glucose = 100; sucrose 65 in the same table). IN CHOCOLATE the glucose response falls (GI 29) but the INSULIN response rises to 82 — against 76 for sugar chocolate; in Livesey's words "maltitol-based chocolate has an II comparable with sucrose-based chocolate", unlike isomalt or erythritol chocolate. A pooled review figure, not a modern ISO-style GI test; none newer was found. DECLARED INTEREST: "This analysis and review was commissioned by the European Polyol Association." | Raises blood glucose more than any other sugar alcohol in this file — GI 35, syrups near 50 — so "sugar-free" maltitol products still need carbohydrate counting.Evert AB et al.; Diabetes Care 42(5):731-754 clinical guidance checked 27 Oct 2026NoteThis record counts half of maltitol's grams, and for maltitol SYRUP even that may under-count (regular syrup GI 52, against sucrose's 65 in the same review). In chocolate, the glucose rise is smaller but the insulin response matches sugar chocolate's (insulin index 82 against 76). The EU health claim is only that it raises glucose less than the sugar it replaces. The ADA's 2019 consensus: little research on benefits of sugar alcohols for people with diabetes, and their GI effects need balancing. Tolerance depends on the form: about 30 g in chocolate was well tolerated, while 20-45 g in water caused diarrhoea in most women tested. |
| Sorbitol | Glycemic index: 9 (glucose = 100)Livesey G, Nutrition Research Reviews 16(2):163-191 peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "This analysis and review was commissioned by the European Polyol Association, to whom the author is grateful for support." The author ran a nutrition consultancy (Independent Nutrition Logic).NotePooled from 10 studies, SD 4; insulinaemic index 11 (SD 6, 6 studies). Glucose = 100; sucrose 65 in the same review (Livesey 2003, Table 5 and abstract). The individual studies used 20-50 g doses, in healthy people and in type 1 and type 2 diabetes. A pooled review figure, not a modern ISO-style GI test. DECLARED INTEREST: the review was commissioned by the European Polyol Association. | Little effect on blood glucose (GI 9), but not calorie-free: 2.6 kcal/g, so this record counts half its grams.Evert AB et al.; Diabetes Care 42(5):731-754 clinical guidance checked 27 Oct 2026NoteAbsorption varies from about a quarter to most of the dose, and what is absorbed becomes fructose and then glycogen or glucose in the liver. The gut usually sets the practical limit before blood glucose does: gas and bloating from about 10 g in one dose. The cardiovascular association is with BLOOD sorbitol, which rises when blood glucose is high, so it cannot be read as a verdict on eating sorbitol. The ADA's 2019 consensus: little research on benefits of sugar alcohols for people with diabetes. |
| Inulin (chicory root fibre) | Glycemic response: Lowers the post-meal rise when it replaces sugar; long-term HbA1c benefit unproven outside one country's trialsWang L, Yang H, Huang H, et al.; Journal… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Chinese public funding; "The authors declare that they have no competing interests."NoteACUTE: two double-blind crossover trials (n=40-42) found that yogurt with 20% less sugar and fruit jelly with 30% less sugar, made up with oligofructose or inulin, lowered the glucose response, and "The reduction of postprandial glycaemia was positively correlated to the proportion of sugars replaced" (Lightowler 2018; two authors at BENEO, an inulin maker). That is a REPLACEMENT effect, which is all the EU's authorised claim says. LONG-TERM: Wang 2019 (33 trials) reports fasting glucose -0.60 mmol/L and HbA1c -0.58% in prediabetes and type 2 diabetes. Its own subgroup table shows where that comes from: across all trials, Iranian trials gave HbA1c -0.75% (-1.00 to -0.50), trials from all other countries -0.08% (-0.27 to 0.11, not significant), and fasting glucose -0.10 (-0.22 to 0.02, not significant); the eight industry-sponsored trials showed nothing (-0.01). No glycaemic index for inulin or oligofructose was found. | The fibre itself does not raise blood glucose, but do not expect it to lower your HbA1c, and count any sugar the label lists.Wang L, Yang H, Huang H, et al.; Journal… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Chinese public funding; "The authors declare that they have no competing interests."NoteReplacing sugar with inulin lowers the post-meal rise in proportion to the sugar removed. The long-term HbA1c benefit in the main meta-analysis disappears outside Iranian trials and in industry-sponsored ones. Commercial inulin can carry free sugars, and acidic foods turn some of it into fructose, so subtract the Dietary Fiber grams, not the ingredient weight. If you have IBS, chicory root fibre is a common trigger. |
| Yacon syrup | Glycemic response: Added to breakfast, it lowered the early glucose peak in one trial; two weeks of daily use did not change fasting glucoseAdriano LS, Dionísio AP, Abreu FAP, Carioca AAF, et… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: Brazilian public funding (CAPES); the syrup was made by Embrapa, the authors' institution.NoteACUTE: 40 women, crossover, breakfast plus 40 g yacon syrup (14 g FOS) or plus placebo: "Glucose and insulin concentrations were lowered after yacon syrup intake as compared to placebo at following times: 30 min for glucose and 15, 30 and 45 min for insulin" (Adriano 2019). That is syrup ADDED to a meal, not syrup in place of sugar. TWO WEEKS: 40 g a day against placebo, 30 completers: "Yacon syrup did not affect blood lipid, glucose or metabolic endotoxemia" (Dionísio 2020). Both trials come from the Embrapa group that makes the syrup they tested. No glycaemic index measured to a standard method was found. | Count it as sugar: a quarter to over half of yacon syrup is free sugar, and this record counts all of its grams.Genta S, Cabrera W, Habib N, Pons J, Manrique… peer reviewed checked 27 Oct 2026Declared interest: "This research was supported by CONICET, CIUNT, ANPCyT (Argentina) and International Potato Center (Peru) grants"; co-author Manrique is CIP staff, and CIP made the syrup. Declared: "There are no conflict of interests."NoteA 20 g tablespoon carries roughly 5-11 g of free sugar on the batches measured, and more if its FOS have broken down. The one acute trial lowered the early glucose peak when syrup was ADDED to breakfast, not when it replaced sugar; two weeks of daily use changed nothing. The weight and insulin results that drive its marketing come from one 2009 trial that compared each group only with itself. |
Some of the notes above mention how a record counts its grams toward net carbs. "Net carbs" is not a recognised measure — start from Total Carbohydrate The American Diabetes Association is explicit: the term "does not have a legal definition and is not used by the Food and Drug Administration or recognized by American Diabetes Association", and the FDA recommends using total carbohydrates on the label. Their reasoning applies directly to the subtraction this site performs: it assumes fibre and sugar alcohols are not absorbed or metabolised, "but this is not always true, and some are partially digested and therefore still provide calories as well as impact blood glucose" — and because the label does not say WHICH sugar alcohol is present, the effect on blood glucose "cannot be determined precisely". Treat the figure above as a formulation aid, not a carbohydrate count to dose insulin against.American Diabetes Association clinical guidance checked 31 Aug 2026
No sweetener here is established to improve long-term health
ADA Standards of Care 2026, Section 5: "NNS do not appear to have a significant effect on glycemic management," and evidence on weight is mixed — some reviews find modest weight-loss benefit, others an association with weight gain, likely reflecting reverse causation and confounding; added to an eating plan without energy restriction, NNS show no weight benefit. Substituting can reduce sugar and calories. That is a different claim from improving an outcome, and only the first is supported. CORROBORATED 2026-08-31 at much larger scale: Jeong et al.'s umbrella review (29 meta-analyses, 24 observational studies plus 6 RCTs, 50M+ participants, 135 associations examined) found observational studies link higher sweetener intake to INCREASED risk of weight gain, metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes and hypertension, while RCTs show only modest weight-loss benefit versus sugar specifically. The two study designs are not measuring the same comparison — see the general-health page for why — but neither supports a durable, independent long-term health benefit, which is the ADA position this guardrail already states.
American Diabetes Association Professional Practice Committee for Diabetes; Diabetes… clinical guidance checked 31 Aug 2026More on reading labels and on lows: Sweeteners and diabetes.
Needs this page does not offer
These are things people reasonably want to filter on. Each would need a judgement or a classification our records do not hold, so they are left out.
- Does not raise blood glucose. Our records hold a measured glycaemic index for some sweeteners and a description in words for others. Drawing a line through either would be our judgement. The section for people managing diabetes shows what each record says instead.
- Plant-derived or natural. Our records do not sort sweeteners into natural and not natural, and this site does not treat "natural" as meaning safer.
- An internationally agreed ADI. Our records show the regulators giving different figures for most sweeteners that have one. The ADI need above asks only whether a number has been set, and names whose.
- Gentle on digestion, low FODMAP, fine with IBS. Tolerance is recorded in the words and units each study used, per sitting or per day. It cannot be turned into a yes or no without inventing a threshold.
- Safe in pregnancy or for children. No record holds a yes-or-no fact for either. Some records carry exposure or risk-assessment notes for these groups; they are on the guides, and this page does not turn them into a yes or a no.
- As sweet as sugar, or measures like sugar. Sweetness is recorded as a range, and a cut-off would be ours.
- Authorised in the EU or the US. Regulatory status is recorded as a short description, not as a yes or no.
- Keto, or good for teeth. Neither is a recorded fact. The dental evidence that some records hold is described on their guides.
How this is calculated
- Each need reads one named fact in each sweetener record. The section for that need says which fact and how it is read.
- Where the fact is a yes-or-no value or a number, the reading follows a fixed rule: a per-gram calorie figure of 0 is Yes, and any figure above 0 is No.
- Where the fact is a sentence, we have classified each record's sentence by hand as Yes, No, or not a plain yes or no. The sentence is shown beside the classification so you can disagree with it. If a record's sentence is later reworded, the classification is withdrawn until someone has read it again.
- A record with no sourced fact for a need is shown as "No sourced figure". It is never counted as Yes or as No.
- Rows stay in the order of our record file. Nothing is ranked, scored or sorted by preference.
- Ticking a need only marks rows on this page, in your browser. Nothing you tick is sent to us or stored.
Where our records hold no sourced figure, this tool says so. It does not estimate one.
Educational information, not medical or dietary advice. This tool does not know your situation and does not tell you what to eat. If you are managing diabetes, are pregnant, take medication, or have a condition affected by what you eat, talk to a clinician or a registered dietitian before acting on anything it shows.
Get told when the sweetener data changes.
This page is educational information, not medical or dietary advice. Nutrition and regulatory details change over time — verify against the cited primary sources before relying on them for formulation or health decisions.