Erythritol vs Sugar
How erythritol compares with table sugar on the things that change a choice: how sweet it is, what it adds in calories, what it does to blood glucose, how it behaves in a recipe and where regulators stand. This page has no figures of its own. Everything below is read from our two sourced records, so when a record is corrected this page changes with it.
At a Glance
Every row below comes from our two sourced records, the same ones the cards at the foot of this page show. Each figure links to the document it came from and the date we last checked it; open “Note” for the qualifications that go with it. Where a record has nothing sourced for a row, the cell says so rather than filling the gap.
| Attribute | Erythritol | Sugar (sucrose) |
|---|---|---|
| Sweetness | 60–80% of sugarEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteSpecification band. Measured potency is concentration-dependent: 0.72 / 0.75 / 0.84 against 5 / 10 / 15% w/v sucrose (Wee 2018); 0.50-0.78 across 3-20% (Fujimaru 2012). | 100% of sugarCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteBy definition. Sucrose IS the reference against which every other figure in this file is expressed. |
| Calories | 0 kcal per gramElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026 | 4 kcal per gramCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteThe general factor for total carbohydrate under 21 CFR 101.9(c)(1)(i)(B). This is the number every "reduced calorie" claim on this site is implicitly measured against. |
| Net carbs | Subtracts in full — none of its grams countElectronic Code of Federal Regulations regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteFDA assigns erythritol 0 cal/g, uniquely among polyols (all others 2.0-3.0). Glycaemic index 0. | Counts in full — all of its grams countCornell Legal Information Institute (eCFR text) regulatory checked 30 Aug 2026NoteCounts in full. This is the 1.0 end of the counted-fraction scale. |
| Blood glucose | 0 (glucose = 100)Livesey G, Nutrition Research Reviews 16:163-191 peer reviewed checked 29 Aug 2026NoteMean 0, SD 17 across 4 studies (glucose = 100). Insulinaemic index 2. The SD is large relative to the mean: this is "no detectable effect", not a precise zero. | 65 (glucose = 100)Livesey G; Nutrition Research Reviews 16(2):163-191 peer reviewed checked 30 Aug 2026NoteGlucose = 100. Sucrose is a glucose-fructose disaccharide, so only about half of it is glucose on hydrolysis — which is why its GI sits below pure glucose rather than at it. |
| Acceptable daily intake | EU 0.5 g per kg body weight per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteEFSA pooled NOAELs for diarrhoea from 10 human studies: range 0.51-1.0 g/kg bw, median 0.75. EFSA adopted the lower bound, 0.5 g/kg bw/day, as its first numerical ADI for erythritol (Dec 2023) and found children's 95th-percentile intake already exceeds it. | No sourced entry |
| Digestive tolerance | 0.5–1 g/kg in one sitting · EU limit 0.5 g/kg per dayEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteEFSA pooled NOAELs for diarrhoea from 10 human studies: range 0.51-1.0 g/kg bw, median 0.75. EFSA adopted the lower bound, 0.5 g/kg bw/day, as its first numerical ADI for erythritol (Dec 2023) and found children's 95th-percentile intake already exceeds it. | No sourced entry |
| Browning | NoneEuropean Commission regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NotePolyols do not participate in Maillard browning; the additive specification caps reducing substances at 0.3% as D-glucose. | No sourced entry |
| Bulk contribution | BulkingEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteUsed as a bulk sweetener, but a 1:1 weight swap under-sweetens because it delivers only 60-80% of sucrose sweetness. | No sourced entry |
| Recrystallisation | HighTyapkova et al. peer reviewed checked 29 Aug 2026NoteLow solubility relative to sucrose; recrystallises on cooling, which is the mechanism behind the gritty or sandy texture in baked goods and frozen desserts. | No sourced entry |
| United States | GRAS by notificationUS Food and Drug Administration regulatory checked 27 Oct 2026NoteSix FDA "no questions" letters, per FDA's GRAS Notice Inventory (checked 2026-10-27): GRN 76 (closed 2001-09-11), 208 (2007-01-25), 382 (2011-11-21), 401 (2012-03-22), 789 (Cargill, 2019-02-20) and 1296 (Shandong Starlight So True, 2026-04-07), the last for erythritol "produced through fermentation of glucose by Yarrowia lipolytica". CORRECTED 2026-10-27: this note previously said six letters ran from GRN 76 through GRN 789, which is five. The production organism now varies by supplier, so prose naming only Moniliella is incomplete. Intended uses in GRN 1296 exclude infant formula and USDA-regulated products. | No sourced entry |
| European Union | Authorised, E 968EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Flavourings, EFSA Journal… regulatory checked 29 Aug 2026NoteVERIFIED DIRECTLY against the EU Food Additives register, 2026-08-31 — do not confuse the two authorisation layers. The substance-specific listing for erythritol shows only ONE category (14.1.4, flavoured drinks, as a flavour enhancer, ML 16000 mg/l, energy-reduced/no-added-sugar only, under Reg (EU) 2015/1832) — reading only that would wrongly suggest erythritol is authorised for almost nothing. The real authorisation is broader: erythritol is a member of GROUP IV, POLYOLS, alongside sorbitol (E420), mannitol (E421), isomalt (E953), maltitol (E965) and xylitol (E967), and Group IV carries its own quantum satis authorisation across roughly 30 food categories (energy-reduced or no-added-sugar foods) under Reg (EU) No 1129/2011. EFSA re-evaluation Dec 2023 established an ADI of 0.5 g/kg bw/day and did not support the requested exemption of erythritol from the laxative warning, which applies to foods with more than 10% added polyols and to every table-top sweetener containing polyols (see laxative_label). | No sourced entry |
Going further
- Erythritol: the full guide, with the evidence and the open questions behind each row.
- Sugar (sucrose): the full guide, the baseline every other sweetener here is measured against.
- Sweetener conversion calculator: a replacement amount by weight, where our records support one.
- Net-carb calculator: what a label’s sweeteners do to the carbohydrate count.
- All comparisons.
New comparisons and corrections, as they land.
This page is educational information, not medical or dietary advice. Nutrition and regulatory details change over time — verify against the cited primary sources before relying on them for formulation or health decisions.